Industrial workers visual

Why do people use the same information system in different ways? New research highlights the role of user agency

Introducing a new information system does not mean that everyone will use it in the same way. Even when employees work with the same technology, their engagement, capabilities and opportunities to contribute to its implementation can differ considerably. 

A new study explores these differences by examining user agency in information system implementation in industrial maintenance. Published in Information Technology & People, the article, Understanding user agency and structural conditions in information system implementation: a study in industrial maintenance, draws on interviews conducted in two industrial companies within the CKIR project AI-ROT. 

The study identifies four types of user agency: eligible, estranged, skilled and motivated. These describe different patterns of how people orient themselves towards information systems, their digital abilities and their contributions to system implementation. Importantly, these are not fixed categories of employees, but different ways in which agency is enacted in practice. The research further highlights three structural conditions that shape users’ capacity to act.  

The findings have practical implications for organizations implementing or renewing information systems. Rather than treating users as a homogeneous group, managers need to recognize different patterns of engagement and consider how working conditions and organizational practices can enable people to make meaningful use of new systems. 

“Successful implementation is not just about introducing a new system or training people to use it. It is also about creating the working conditions that allow people to engage with the system, learn, contribute and make it part of their everyday work,” says Heini Ikävalko, Research Manager at Aalto University’s School of Business Center for Knowledge and Innovation Research.  

Read the article: 

Authors: Heini Ikävalko, Miia Martinsuo and Elviira Saarelma

Go to all News.